Friday, 14 March 2008

So what will Butterfly World do for our butterflies?

Its an interesting question.

My personal opinion is that I think Clive Farrell and his team should be congratulated for getting butterflies in the media spotlight. The project at St Albans will be great for butterflies and for educating people about ourenvironment. It will also help raise much needed cash to help ourbutterflies through Butterfly Conservation.

However, until our government, the EU and the general public wake upto the sorry state we are in when it comes to wildlife in the UK,then we will never make any progress, no matter how much money is spent on or raised by such a wonderful project.

Farmers get a raw deal for the produce they grow and increased human population in the UK results in even less farmland (due to increased house bulding and associated roads and other infrastucture) and higher food prices... both of which combine to place huge presure onour wildlife.

Reports that the loss of EU set-aside funding will result in a population crash of Wild Hare (for example) will certainly also effect our butterflies. Uncontrolled cutting of hedgerows due to loss of farming subsidies means species like the Brown Hairstreak will suffer (as reported at Grafton Wood, in Worcestershire).

The lack of joined up thinking by apparently 'clever' people who run this country is not a result of a lack of inteligence, far from it,its a result of a culture dominated by big business, money and greed. So, although this is a great project which should be celebrated for its educational value, I wonder what could be done with £25 Million out in the wider countryside? I also wonder what the project impact will be in terms of traffic and polution in the St Albans area?

There are lots of positives and lots of negatives to this project. What we really need however is a government which rather than year on year cuts environmental budgets, it increases them. Until that happens I fear that we may see further species extinctions in the UK. A huge butterfly dome will not save wild butterflies (such as the High Brown Fritilary) if their habitats are destroyed through so called 'development' no matter how much money it raises for Butterfly Conservation.

Should we instead, encourage the general public to go out into the countryside and see and protect butterflies in the wild rather than create a culture where our children will only ever see animals in a zoo?

As A child, I remember seeing lots of butterflies in our garden. Today, the same garden is rarely visited by butterflies because the garden is now so much further away from the countryside. Children now growing up in the same street have never seen a butterfly in the 'wild' let alone collected caterpillars from a nettle patch down the road. Our countryside is being sanitised (field upon field of extensive farming practices, excessive road verge cutting, hedgerow cutting and gardens converted to block-paved eyesores) yet we don'tseem to care about the plastic bags tangled in trees and lining ourstreets. If we did, there would be more urgency to make the change.

I hope the St Albans project is a success. Its just a shame that we have to re-create habitats at a tourist attraction in order to educate people about the importance of butterflies and wildlife as a whole.

4 comments:

Warren Baker said...

An excellent article,
You've hit the nail on the head, when you talk about habitat destruction. In the arera I live (Tonbridge) The countryside is systematcally being cleansed of all those little places that were once wild and neglected. This in turn wipes out our breeding, birds , butterflies and other wildlife. I believe the only way forward, is for all wildlife organisations, to come together for the common good.

Steve said...

Neat blog Steve i have linked you to my blog (www.newhythe.blogspot.com) where I record my butterfly sightings as well as birds & other wildlife.
I was reading this morning about the decline of small tortoisehell a butterfly that has disappeared from my Kent patch. Apparently there is some research being undertaken by Oxford Uni that the cause is a tiny parasitic fly Sturmia bella. They reckon the caterpillar eats the flys eggs which then hatch, killing the host. Grusome.

British Butterflies said...

Thanks for your comments guys.

Sadly we live in a world where those in control (Councils, Governments etc) seem to thank that a grassy verge full of wild flowers and insects is untidy... they forget that when the verges are cut we can see all the disgarded plastic bags and other rubbish which pollutes our environment.

We need more wild areas and sadly, our countryside is in such a state that some of the best wildlife sites are on road and motorway verges (when they are left uncut!!). Not perhaps somewhere you would want to visit for s sunday afternoon stroll!!

As for the Small Tortoiseshell, well it is suffering from the Sturmia bella paristic fly. The population is also struggling because every stinging nettle patch which may come into contact with a human being is cut back (no doubt for health and saftey reasons) and this means less food for the catterpillars... less caterpillars and even fewer Small Tortoiseshell butterflies... add to that the Sturmia bella parasite and the poor old Small Tortoiseshell doesn't have much chance.

I think for the whole of 2007, I saw about 20 Small Tortoiseshell butterflies, yet this used to be one of our commonest species.

British Butterflies said...

Thanks for the link Steve

Had a look at you blog. Superb pics of Grass Snake and Water Vole... not so common up here in the midlands unfortunately!!